Sources, already read
- DraftDOCX Statement of work: three deliverables, six sites, 20 weeksread
- ProposalsPDF Three proposals, with their staffing plansread
- Rate cardsXLSX Each firm's titles, rates and stated discountsread
- Accounts payableCSV Invoices from the last three consulting engagementssynced
- PolicyPDF Travel and expense policyread
Connected to the systems where your team already keeps these files. Your team chooses which ones Zinit reads.
Titles mapped to experience
Bid B's Consultant and Bid C's Consultant sit a level apart, and Bid C's Director sits where Bid B's Manager does, so your team confirms the map before any rate is compared.
Hours by deliverable
Bid C's diagnostic covers two sites at 280 hours each. The other four are outside its scope, and step 5 prices them.
What each proposal assumes
Bid C's fee assumes your team gathers the data at each site, which is three times the hours Bid B asks for.
The bid tab, on one scope
Bid A the firm the sponsor has in mind
- Fee as proposed
- $2,224,000
- Expenses
- $222,400
- Sites left out
- $0
- Your people's hours
- $25,500
- Total on the same scope
- $2,471,900
Bid B a specialist firm from the search
- Fee as proposed
- $1,426,000
- Expenses
- $114,080
- Sites left out
- $0
- Your people's hours
- $42,500
- Total on the same scope
- $1,582,580
Bid C a partner-led boutique
- Fee as proposed
- $924,600
- Expenses
- $55,476
- Sites left out
- $488,000
- Your people's hours
- $127,500
- Total on the same scope
- $1,595,576
Bid C's $501k lead on the proposed fee becomes a $13k gap the other way, so price has stopped deciding between Bid B and Bid C.
The percentage for expenses and the hours for your own people come from step 4. Your team confirms each line before finance sees it.
Award, three ways
Award Bid B
The lowest total on the same scope, with a mid-sized team and a capped expense line.
$1,582,580
Award Bid C
A more senior team, within $13k of Bid B, with the highest rate for added work.
$1,595,576
Keep Bid A, on Bid B's plan
The sponsor's firm at its own rates, on Bid B's hours by level: $1,908,600 in fees, with its 10% expenses and Bid B's 500 client hours.
$2,141,960
If the sponsor keeps Bid A's firm and it accepts that plan, the company still spends $330k less than Bid A as proposed, and the sign-off records a premium of $559k over Bid B.
If a second business unit joins in week 10
480 more hours at each bid's rate for added work: Bid A $510, Bid B $446, Bid C $610.
The change takes Bid B's lead over Bid C from $13k to $92k, which is the line that decides between them.
Your team awards. Zinit records the award, the leveled table and each proposal's terms.