Financial services procurement that prices banks, merchant services and payroll providers on your own volumes.
Banks bill through an account analysis statement whose earnings credit rate they set themselves, acquirers fold interchange into one rate, and payroll and broker fees each come in a format of their own, so the incumbent's price is hard to test. Zinit's AI agents build one pro forma from your own twelve months of volumes, every bidder prices the same lines, and the cost of switching becomes a line of its own.
−$1,643.83No unit price on this statement changed since March. The bank lowered its earnings credit rate from 2.00% to 1.50% at its own discretion, so the same balances now earn $1,643.83 less credit a month, or $20,000 a year.
What the earnings credit rate is worth on the example's balances
A year of earnings credit on $4,000,000 of investable balance
1.25%Bank A's quote$50,000
1.50%The incumbent in September$60,000
1.75%Bank B's quote$70,000
2.00%The incumbent in March$80,000
Each quarter point is $10,000 a year on these balances. The FOMC held the federal funds target range at 3-3/4 to 4 percent on October 28, 2026; the two new bids quote their rates 2.50 and 2.00 points below its lower bound, while the incumbent sets its rate at its own discretion.
The example company's treasury services over a five-year term
$182,820between renewing as is and awarding Bank B, with the cost of switching paid
Renew as is5 years × ($107,184 of charges − $60,000 of earnings credit)$235,920
Renew at the incumbent's best and final5 years × ($85,747 of charges − $70,000 of earnings credit)$78,735
Award Bank B5 years × ($76,620 of charges − $70,000 of earnings credit) + $60,000 conversion − $40,000 credit$53,100
Every line uses the same twelve-month volumes and the same $4,000,000 of investable balance, and the conversion line is the company's own estimate of moving banks.
Five financial services, each billed in a format that resists a side-by-side comparison.
Each service is owned by a different desk and billed in its own format, and each has its own reason a company stays with the provider it has. The comparison that holds up is built the same way every time: your own volumes, every bidder on the same lines, and the switch priced.
Banking and treasury services
Decides Treasury, with the CFO; payables, receivables and IT run the files the bank sends and receives.
The document that sets the price
The monthly account analysis statement: each service with its AFP Service Code, volume, unit price and charge, then the balances, the earnings credit rate and the net fee.
What a fair comparison prices
Unit prices times your twelve-month volumes, the earnings credit rate quoted against an index on the same balances, whether excess credit carries forward, and the conversion credit each bank offers.
What keeps you with the incumbent
Payment, positive pay and reconciliation files rebuilt and tested with the ERP, lockbox mail redirected, payers given new account details, and a new bank's beneficial-ownership checks, which a company skips when it only adds accounts at its current bank.
Where Zinit fits Builds the pro forma from your statements and levels every bid over the term.
Card acceptance and merchant services
Decides Finance, usually treasury, with whoever runs the stores or the online checkout.
The document that sets the price
The merchant statement and the acquirer's pricing schedule: interchange set by Visa and Mastercard, network fees, and the acquirer's own markup, either folded into one rate or listed apart.
What a fair comparison prices
The markup over interchange and network fees, priced on your own twelve months of card mix, in-store and online sales, regulated and exempt debit, and the enhanced data your commercial-card sales send, which decides the rate they qualify for.
What keeps you with the incumbent
Early termination fees, equipment leases that can outlast the processing agreement, PCI validation through the new acquirer, and stored card data that moves only to another PCI DSS Level 1 processor and comes back under new identifiers.
Where Zinit fits Restates every bid as interchange plus a markup on your own transactions.
Payroll services
Decides The payroll lead, with HR and finance.
The document that sets the price
The provider's quote: a monthly base, a fee per employee, the pay runs, states and year-end forms it includes, and add-ons for time tracking and HR.
What a fair comparison prices
Each quote on your headcount, pay frequency, states and Forms W-2 over the term, with implementation and the parallel run.
What keeps you with the incumbent
Year-to-date wages and deposits have to be loaded so the Form W-3 reconciles with four Forms 941, and state accounts re-authorized. A January 1 start avoids moving history, and a quarter start keeps each Form 941 with one provider.
Where Zinit fits Puts every provider's quote on the same headcount and calendar. Your company stays liable for its employment taxes with a payroll service provider; only a certified PEO is generally liable in its place for the wages it pays.
Insurance brokerage
Decides Risk management, or the CFO or treasurer where there is no risk department; HR for the benefits broker.
The document that sets the price
The broker's compensation: commission from insurers, fees from you, and contingent or volume-based pay. A broker to a group health plan has to disclose it in writing under ERISA section 408(b)(2)(B).
What a fair comparison prices
Brokers on their total compensation in dollars and the service they commit to, before any insurer is approached.
What keeps you with the incumbent
Most insurers discuss an account only with its agent of record, so a change takes a new letter, and public broker RFPs bar proposers from approaching insurers until one broker is chosen.
Where Zinit fits Runs the broker selection on compensation and service, and leaves the insurers to the broker your team selects.
External audit and advisory
Decides The audit committee, for a listed company; a board or council for most public bodies.
The document that sets the price
Each firm's proposal: staffing, hours and hourly rates, the fee, its peer review report and its independence statement. A listed company's proxy shows audit fees in four categories.
What a fair comparison prices
Proposals side by side, with quality weighed first. Two public audit RFPs from 2025 gave fees 15% and 20% of the score.
What keeps you with the incumbent
Institutional knowledge, fees the committee judges in line with peers, and the cost and distraction of a change, which a listed company also reports on Form 8-K.
Where Zinit fits Prepares the request the committee approves and lays the proposals out side by side. The committee interviews the firms and appoints one.
A bank or insurer buying critical services for its own operations faces a different test, the exit plan its supervisors ask about, which the finance industry page covers.
Five reasons a financial-services renewal goes through without a real comparison.
Every one of these markets has several large providers, so the reasons lie in how each bill is written and how hard the switch looks from inside.
Item 01
The bank prices the statement at its own discretion. The earnings credit rate can change without notice, a reserve deduction the Federal Reserve dropped in 2020 can still sit on the page, and a balance assessment rides on top, so the net fee moves while no unit price does.
What Zinit doesEvery bank quotes its earnings credit rate against the federal funds target range, with a floor and its history, and every bid is read on the same balances.
Item 02
A blended card rate hides the mix. Visa's consumer credit interchange alone runs from 1.43% to 3.15% plus 10 cents, depending on the card and the data sent with the sale, and the OCC's handbook says most merchant agreements let the acquirer raise rates and fees during the term.
What Zinit doesEvery acquirer prices the same twelve months of your transactions as interchange plus a markup, so the markup is the number your team compares.
Item 03
The switch is guessed at, never priced. Files have to be rebuilt and tested, lockbox mail redirected, stored card data exported only to another Level 1 processor, and state payroll accounts re-authorized, so the incumbent wins by default.
What Zinit doesYour own estimate of the conversion becomes a line on the bid tab, and every bidder is asked for its conversion credit or implementation fee.
Item 04
Brokers cannot be compared on premium, because insurers usually work only with the broker of record and two brokers shopping the same program block each other's markets.
What Zinit doesBrokers are compared first, on their compensation in dollars and the service they commit to, and only the broker your team selects goes to the insurers.
Item 05
The audit fee sits outside procurement's authority. The audit committee of a listed company appoints and pays the auditor, and it cannot hand its pre-approval of services to management.
What Zinit doesZinit prepares the request the committee approves, collects each firm's proposal, peer review report and independence statement, and sets the fees out in the proxy's four categories for the committee to decide.
How Zinit runs a financial-services RFP.
The three moves are the same whichever service renews next, and Zinit's AI agents do the reading and the arithmetic while your team decides, drawing on a 103M+ supplier and company database for the bidder list.
1
Count your own volumes
Zinit reads twelve months of analysis statements, merchant statements or payroll summary reports and builds the pro forma every bidder prices, line by line, with your volumes and balances.
One request that every bidder answers on the same lines.
2
Widen the bidder list
Zinit adds qualified providers that serve companies of your size and footprint, and your team approves every invitation, the incumbent's included. The first RFP is drafted in under an hour, and the bids take the time they take.
Three or more comparable bids, the incumbent's among them.
3
Level with the switch priced in
Each bid is restated over the term on the same balances, transaction mix or headcount, with your conversion cost and the bidder's credit as lines of their own.
An award your treasurer, CFO or committee can defend line by line.
Sometimes the incumbent is still the right provider, and then your team renews at the price the bids set. Zinit does not open accounts, approve providers, place insurance or appoint auditors, and your team directs and approves every step.
A lockbox move redirects every one of these envelopes, so the switch gets its own line on the bid tab.
The worked example: a treasury services RFP, from the statements to the conversion.
Every figure belongs to the example company, a US distributor with ten accounts at one bank. Its volumes come from its own analysis statements, its balances are held the same for every bid, and its unit prices sit inside what public banking contracts from 2016 to 2023 show: online outgoing wires at $2.50 to $8.00, and ACH items at $0.02 to $0.065.
Zinit · Treasury services RFP · Example company
Twelve months of statements, read where they already live
Bank portalPDF Account analysis statements, October to September, all ten accountsRead
Bank portalcamt.086 Billing statement files for the same months, with AFP Service CodesRead
ERPBAI2 Previous-day files, for the ACH and wire countsSynced
Contract repositoryPDF Treasury services agreement and fee schedule, with the earnings credit clauseSynced
From the fee schedule
The earnings credit rate is set by the Bank at its discretion and may be changed without notice. Excess earnings credits do not carry forward beyond the calendar month.
One pro forma, priced by every bank on the company's own volumes
10Services, each with its AFP code
12Months of statements read
5Years, prices firm
What every bank is asked for
A unit price for every line, firm for five years
The earnings credit rate as a spread to the lower bound of the federal funds target range, with a floor and 24 months of history
Whether excess earnings credit carries forward, and for how long
Every conversion cost to the company, and the conversion credit the bank will pay
A sample analysis statement priced on these volumes, with AFP codes
Public banking RFPs from 2025 and 2026 ask for these same things: pricing by AFP Service Code on the buyer's volumes, the earnings credit rate against a market index, carry-forward, and conversion costs and credits.
Banks invited, with the incumbent rebidding on the same pro forma
5Banks invited, the incumbent included
3Bids received
28Days to bids
Screened for
Treasury management in every state the company operates in
Positive pay with payee validation, and ACH debit blocks
Analysis statements in camt.086 or X12 822 files
BAI2 previous-day files into the ERP
Asked of every bidder
Sample analysis statement on these volumes
Conversion plan with tasks, owners and dates
Earnings credit rate history, 24 months
A named conversion manager
Nobody was contacted until your team approved the list. Two banks declined to bid.
The bid tab: every line priced on the same volumes, the same balances and the same five years
Service
Volume a year
Incumbentrenewal at current prices
Bank Ainvited by your team
Bank Badded by Zinit, approved by your team
01 0000 Account maintenance
120
$15.00
$7.00
$10.00
10 0224 Deposited checks, electronic
108,000
$0.10
$0.07
$0.08
15 0030 Positive pay with payee validation, base
36
$30.00
$15.00
$20.00
15 0100 Checks paid
18,000
$0.10
$0.05
$0.07
25 0102 ACH originated item
480,000
$0.05
$0.025
$0.035
25 0202 ACH received item
72,000
$0.05
$0.03
$0.03
35 0100 Outgoing domestic wire, online
3,600
$6.00
$3.00
$4.00
35 0300 Incoming domestic wire
4,800
$4.20
$2.50
$3.00
05 0100 Lockbox item processed
48,000
$0.35
$0.20
$0.25
00 0230 Balance assessment, per $1,000 of average ledger
50,400
$0.11
$0.13
$0.10
Analyzed charges a year
$107,184
$62,952
$76,620
Earnings credit rate quoted
1.50%, at the bank's discretion
1.25%: lower bound less 2.50
1.75%: lower bound less 2.00
Earnings credit a year, on $4,000,000
−$60,000
−$50,000
−$70,000
Net fees a year
$47,184
$12,952
$6,620
Net fees, five years
$235,920
$64,760
$33,100
Conversion cost, company estimate
None
+$60,000
+$60,000
Conversion credit
None
−$25,000
−$40,000
Five-year cost
$235,920
$99,760
$53,100
Incumbentrenewal at current prices
Analyzed charges a year
$107,184
Earnings credit rate quoted
1.50%
Earnings credit a year, on $4,000,000
−$60,000
Net fees, five years
$235,920
Conversion less the bank's credit
None
Five-year cost
$235,920
Bank Ainvited by your team
Analyzed charges a year
$62,952
Earnings credit rate quoted
1.25%
Earnings credit a year, on $4,000,000
−$50,000
Net fees, five years
$64,760
Conversion less the bank's credit
+$35,000
Five-year cost
$99,760
Bank Badded by Zinit, approved by your team
Analyzed charges a year
$76,620
Earnings credit rate quoted
1.75%
Earnings credit a year, on $4,000,000
−$70,000
Net fees, five years
$33,100
Conversion less the bank's credit
+$20,000
Five-year cost
$53,100
The company's conversion estimate, for ten accounts and one ERP
Rebuild and test ACH, positive pay and BAI2 files with the ERP$30,000
Run old and new accounts in parallel for two months$12,000
Redirect lockbox mail and send payers the new remittance details$10,000
Set up accounts, online banking users and ACH debit blocks, and train staff$8,000
Conversion cost, company estimate$60,000
Bank A has the lowest unit prices and Bank B the better earnings credit rate, and on $4,000,000 of balances the rate decides it. In every month each bid's charges exceed its earnings credit, a 31-day month included, so no credit would expire under any of them.
The incumbent's best and final, against Bank B
AwardBank B at its bid
Bank B's earnings credit rate follows the federal funds target range at 2.00 points below its lower bound, and its $40,000 conversion credit covers two thirds of the company's estimate.
Five-year cost
$53,100
Against renewing as is
$182,820 less
Runner-upIncumbent's best and final
The incumbent matched Bank B's rate, 2.00 points below the lower bound, and cut every unit price by 20%.
Five-year cost
$78,735
Against Bank B
$25,635 more
Your treasurer and CFO awarded Bank B. The incumbent's best and final stayed $25,635 higher over five years, with the cost of the switch already counted against Bank B.
The conversion plan, owned task by task
Task
Owner
Weeks
Open the accounts and complete the new bank's due diligence, beneficial owners included
Treasury
1 to 2
Set up online banking users, entitlements and ACH debit blocks
Treasury
2 to 3
Rebuild and test ACH, positive pay and BAI2 files with the ERP
IT and payables
2 to 6
Redirect lockbox mail and send payers the new remittance details
Receivables
3 to 6
Run old and new accounts in parallel, then close the old ones
Treasury and payables
6 to 14
RecalculatedFive-year cost on these volumes: $53,100, which is $182,820 under renewing as is.
The prices and dates a finance team already watches.
Each figure is dated and comes from its publisher, at the foot of the page. They change, which is why the comparison is built on your own volumes and this year's prices.
3-3/4 to 4%
The federal funds target range the FOMC held on October 28, 2026, and the index a bank can quote its earnings credit rate against.
Federal Reserve, FOMC statement, October 28, 2026
21¢ + 0.05%
The debit interchange cap Visa and Mastercard still apply. The Eighth Circuit affirmed its vacatur on October 26, 2026, effective only once the court's mandate issues.
12 CFR 235.3; Eighth Circuit, Corner Post v. Board of Governors, October 26, 2026
$0.23 vs $0.51
Average interchange on a regulated debit transaction against an exempt one, across all networks in 2024.
Federal Reserve debit card data, published December 19, 2025
February 1, 2027
When 2026 Forms W-2 are due to employees and the Social Security Administration.
IRS, General Instructions for Forms W-2 and W-3 (2026)
+0.2%
The average change in US commercial property and casualty premiums across all account sizes in the fourth quarter of 2025, with commercial auto up 6.6%.
The Council of Insurance Agents & Brokers, February 18, 2026
17%
The share of S&P 500 proxy statements that say the audit committee is responsible for negotiating the audit fee.
Center for Audit Quality and Audit Analytics, December 2025
Visa credit interchange on a $100 sale in a store, by card
Visa USA interchange reimbursement fees, effective October 24, 2026; each rate plus $0.10
Traditional and all other consumer credit1.43% + $0.10 · Retail credit, performance threshold I$1.53
Visa Signature1.65% + $0.10 · Retail credit, performance threshold I$1.75
Visa Infinite, spend not qualified1.90% + $0.10 · Retail credit, performance threshold I$2.00
Non-qualified consumer credit3.15% + $0.10 · Where a sale lands when it misses a program's criteria$3.25
Interchange is the same whichever acquirer processes the sale, so bids differ in the markup and fees on top. That is why every bid is restated as interchange plus a markup on your own twelve months of cards.
The providers in each service, and the comparison each one takes.
Every one of these markets has large, established providers, and in most of them a mid-size company can also choose among regional banks, specialist processors, payroll platforms and smaller brokerages and firms.
ServiceBid them onEstablished providers
Treasury management
Unit prices on your volumes by AFP code, the earnings credit rate against an index, and a conversion credit
Established providers
Bank of America
Wells Fargo
Card acceptance
The markup over interchange and network fees on your own card mix
Established providers
Adyen
Payroll
Base and per-employee fees on your headcount, states and year-end forms
Established providers
Insurance brokerage
Total compensation in dollars and the service committed, before insurers are approached
Established providers
Brown & Brown
External audit
Staffing, hours and fees side by side, for the audit committee to weigh
Established providers
Established suppliers in each category, shown to illustrate the market, not as a list of Zinit's customers or partners.
What competitive events have returned elsewhere.
One approved outcome from a customer's events, and companies whose teams have published RFPs on Zinit.
Manufacturing
23% savings across procurement categories
An industrial manufacturer's result across its own sourcing events, shown in the context where it was measured.
RFPs published from
Companies whose teams have published RFPs on Zinit.
Questions a finance team asks first.
What does it cost?
Zinit is supplier-funded and free to buyers: only the supplier your team selects as the winner pays a commission, the losing bidders pay nothing, and nothing is owed until you award. The commission rates are published openly on our site, and because the fee is tied to the award your team makes rather than to who competes, Zinit earns the same whichever qualified supplier you choose.
Won't a bank price your fee back into its bid?
It could, through a higher unit price or a thinner earnings credit, and both sit on the bid tab, where the five-year cost takes them in before anyone compares banks. The fee itself comes from the fee schedule in Zinit's terms of service: on the example's award to Bank B, five years of analyzed charges at $383,100, it is a $250 flat fee plus 0.45% of the RFP volume, about $2,000 once, or about $33 a month against the $6,385 a month those charges run to. A treasurer who would rather keep it out of the pricing can, since the same terms let the buyer elect to carry the fee when the RFP is published.
Does Zinit choose our auditor?
No. For a listed company the audit committee appoints, pays and oversees the auditor and pre-approves every service it provides. Zinit prepares the request the committee approves, collects the proposals with each firm's peer review report and independence statement, and sets the fees out the way the proxy shows them. Firms may propose before speaking to your current auditor, which answers their questions only once the committee has chosen.
Does Zinit contact insurers?
No. Your team selects a broker first, on compensation and service, and that broker markets the program to insurers. Proposers are asked not to approach insurers during the selection, which keeps the markets open for the broker you choose.
We pay one blended card rate. Can the bids still be compared?
Yes. Merchant statements show your volumes, and where a blended statement hides the card mix your team asks the acquirer for the mix report. Every acquirer then prices that mix as interchange plus its markup and fees, so the blended rate becomes one bid among comparable ones.
When can we change payroll providers?
At any time, once year-to-date wages and deposits are loaded and a parallel run checks the first payroll. January 1 avoids moving any history, and the start of a quarter keeps each Form 941 with one provider. Your company stays liable for its employment taxes with a payroll service provider; only a certified PEO is generally liable in its place for the wages it pays.
What do the bidders see?
Only the request your team approves: the services, the volumes and balances by line, and the terms you ask for. Statements, account numbers and contracts stay with your team, and nobody, the incumbent included, is contacted until your team approves the list.
Who runs the event?
Zinit's AI agents run it, and Zinit's procurement people work alongside your team. Your team approves every invitation and decides every award.
Bring twelve months of statements.
Start with the bank, card or payroll contract that renews next. Zinit reads the statements, builds the pro forma and runs the event, with your team directing and approving every step.
[5] J.P. Morgan, Account Analysis Statement Guide (October 16, 2025)Earnings credit allowance = average investable balance × ECR × days in month / days in year; balance-based and fee-based charges; a reserve line not currently in use; carry-forward within longer settlement cycles
Zinit's AI-native procurement platform supports indirect procurement optimization with repeatable sourcing events and a renewal calendar your team directs.